Despite its well-known brand, convenient locations, and considerable scale, the no-moat retailer is unattractive at its current price.
Erin Lash, CFA
08:20 AM | Email Article
We don’t expect a material change to our $74 fair value estimate for Target
following tepid second-quarter results, which included a 1.1% comparable-store sales decline and flat operating margins at 7.7%. In light of a challenging operating landscape, management lowered its 2016 adjusted earnings per share guidance to $4.80-$5.20 from $5.20-$5.40; we had already viewed the prior range as a bit stretched, as our estimate stood at $5.08. Despite the firm’s more muted near-term outlook, we’re holding the line on our long-term forecast for 3% annual sales growth and 7.5% average margins over the decade.
Erin Lash, CFA, is a director of consumer sector equity research for Morningstar.
Even with the mid-single-digit retreat in the share price, we’d suggest investors await a more attractive risk/reward opportunity, given the continued headwinds for Target. We believe Target possesses a well-known brand, convenient locations, and considerable scale; however, its product mix skews toward categories that go head to head with Amazon. Further, at $2.5 billion in 2015, digital sales accounted for just 3.5% of Target’s total sales base, and as such, the firm lacks a cost edge to defend itself against established online competitors (Wal-Mart generates more than $13 billion in online sales and Amazon generates more than $100 billion), supporting our no-moat rating.
Although digital channel sales increased 16% on top of a 30% jump in last year’s second quarter (reflecting a 0.5% comp), this growth is coming off a very low base. Target’s same-store sales (excluding digital) slipped 1.6%, as the retailer has fallen victim to the challenges experienced across the sector. Traffic slumped 2.2%, with particular weakness in electronics and grocery, while prices increased 2.6% and units per transaction ticked down 0.5%. To offset these pressures, Target will probably need to cut prices to drive traffic if sales growth remains persistently low, resulting in negative operating leverage and margin contraction.
Morningstar Premium Members gain exclusive access to our full analyst reports, including fair value estimates, bull and bear breakdowns, and risk analyses. Not a Premium Member? Get this and other reports immediately when you try Morningstar Premium free for 14 days.